Jack Layton Replies to My Letter on Behalf of Libby Davies

Subtitle: “Pinning the Tail on the Other Donkey”

What follows, is the full text of Jack Layton’s “reply” to the open letter I sent him and other political leaders in defence of Libby Davies’ criticism of Israel. (You’ll notice he doesn’t bother to address me personally…not that it matters).

Jack Layton, Leader NDP Canada

Thank you for your message, I appreciate you taking the time to send us
your comments.

First, let me be clear that the position of the NDP with regard to the ongoing conflict in the Middle East has not changed, a position that was democratically adopted at a Convention of our delegates from across Canada.  Our party has always been principled and constructive in how it addresses this complex issue; we recognize the right of both Israelis and Palestinians to live in peaceful co-existence in viable, independent states with negotiated, agreed-upon borders. We are committed to working with like-minded allies in the region to make concrete and lasting progress toward peace.

Both myself and our Foreign Affairs critic Paul Dewar are regularly in touch with representatives of Middle East governments. For example, I was in touch with the Turkish ambassador following the flotilla raid and am regularly in touch with the Israeli ambassador and Palestinian representatives here in Canada. Last year, I also met with president of the Palestinian Authorities Mahmud Abbas and had an excellent meeting where I had the opportunity to outline the NDP’s policies on this issue.

We strongly believe that the Canadian government should play a key role in facilitating the kind of talks and negotiations that are desperately needed to finally achieve peace in the Middle East. Canada should use the skills and approaches that were once our signature on the international stage – an approach the Harper government has largely abandoned.

For example, we called on the government to reinstate and increase Canada’s contribution to UNRWA – in order to see improvements to the lives of ordinary Palestinians. We have also called on the government to join international efforts to ease the blockade of Gaza and better address the human suffering in the region.

On issues that divide Canadians, New Democrats have tried to build as much common ground as possible around our caucus table. This kind of collegial approach builds a strong team, one that can stand up to Stephen Harper and speak as one voice on critical issues. By working together as a caucus, we achieve better results for progressive Canadians. And when we have different views on the way we approach an issue, it’s important that we work through those differences in a constructive manner, like a family. New Democrats will always work to create opportunities to build bridges between conflicting perspectives, as much as possible.

As for Libby’s comments, she quickly clarified her comments and I accepted her clarification. She has ably served for 7 years in the crucial position of NDP House Leader and continues to carry out these duties, as well as serving as Deputy Leader for me and for our caucus. Like you, I have the utmost respect for Libby as a person and as an activist.

Our Deputy Leaders, Libby Davies and Thomas Mulcair, are key members of
our caucus team, a team that has been so effective in holding Harper to
account. Both Tom and Libby have my full confidence. Working together,
and with our whole caucus, they will be a crucial part of our fight to take on Stephen Harper on issues like pension security, fighting catastrophic climate change and protecting consumers.

Working together, we will defeat the Stephen Harper Conservatives.

Once again, I thank you for taking the time to write to me.

Sincerely,

Jack

(My Response to Mr. Layton’s letter tomorrow).