reed writes » 2006 » February

healthcare * please read urgently * click here

Saturday, February 11th, 2006

I am seriously hoping that Mr. Harper and his group do not contemplate anything hasty or rash with respect to any changes in our healthcare system. The only tampering required is more money to bring the system up to scratch.

Canadians spend approximately 9.5% of GDP on healthcare, while the Americans, with their multi-payer system spend about 15% of GDP on healthcare and yet they still have more than 45 million citizens without any insurance.

A recent poll in the United States shows that more than 70% of ordinary Americans would like to have the Canadian system.

Back in 1994, Jack Smith, a former CEO of General Motors went on record as “personally favor[ing] the Canadian system.” Smith, an anomaly ten years ago, today looks like the weatherman who knew which way the wind was blowing. The volume and intensity of anguished, bitter public complaints by business executives about the costs and burdens of health care has grown to major proportions.

Cast The First Stone

Sunday, February 5th, 2006

A few bloggers and others are taking a somewhat cavalier approach to Muslim demonstrations against the anti-Islam cartoons that appeared recently in a Danish newspaper and which were subsequently republished around the world. These critics are asking why moderate Muslims have been relatively quiescent in the face of some of the violence that has resulted in the torching of Scandinavian embassies and wild threats against the west.

Red Tory is one of those who condemns the violence (good), but who takes a more or less light-hearted view of the situation in his blog today, February 6th 2006. As a form of protest against the violence- he vows to go on a shopping spree for Danish cheese and beer.

http://redtory.blogspot.com/

I’m not inclined just yet to cast stones at moderate Muslims, or to poke fun at the protests.

Anger, fear, shame, embarrassment, astonishment, – these and other emotions are no doubt being processed by many Muslims around the world. As happens so often, we north americans are interested in the quick fix and the instant response. Our society and our culture mandate it. Sometimes impatient westerners need to think before demanding an eye for an eye or a Tuborg for a slice of bacon.

My feeling is that millions of Muslims are probably praying right now for some sort of guidance as to how to react to all this. Just as it’s difficult for us to grasp the depth of Cindy Sheehan’s grief, or fully understand the real motivation behind some of her bizarre behaviour, it’s also difficult for us to understand the depth of Muslim feeling toward what they believe and feel is the hate-inciting depiction of the Prophet.

We used to believe that all Jews were a threat, either because they were Communists or Bankers supposedly. Our newspapers and magazines published degrading and humiliating cartoons of Jews; out of fear and hate- we prohibited Jews from immigrating to Canada during the time of their greatest crisis. (see Irving Abella ). We barred them from our clubs and from our society columns.

http://www.cdn-friends-icej.ca/antiholo/non2many.html

(Eventually, we stopped doing that because they got very angry and finally we saw our Jewish friends’ anguish and humiliation and the terrible threat to their religion, society and to their very lives). The Jews fought back and established a secure Homeland for themselves, courtesy the United Nations and their own dogged determination, tempered by an unwillingness to suffer further insults. But unfortunately, they secured their dignity only through violence and military superiority and not through any largesse of so-called Christian nations.

Now they have the bomb and nobody messes with them. The cost of degrading and humiliating whole groups of people can be inordinately high.

Maybe it’s time to stop and think about that.

Failure to learn from the mistakes of our past means that we may be doomed to repeat them.

Canadian Healthcare In Danger

Friday, February 3rd, 2006
THE THREAT TO OUR HEALTHCARE SYSTEM IS REAL

A lot of American insurance companies, many international drug companies, a few Canadian doctors and some deeply offensive Canadian politicians want to privatize our health care system. The one we have isn’t perfect, and it does need more funds, as our population ages, but it’s better than the alternative.

Those who have to wait a few months for hip replacements and other non-emergency health services and procedures have my greatest sympathy. However, that situation could easily be remedied by an adequate investment in the single-payer system we have in this country.

At the moment, Canada spends about 10% of its gross domestic product on healthcare. The Americans, whose system some Canadians would like to copy, spend about 15% of their GDP on healthcare and yet more than 45 million Americans are without health insurance of any kind. Millions more have insurance that doesn’t cover many of the procedures and treatments covered by our single-payer system. (72% of Americans say they’d like to have the Canadian system in their country).

Inexplicably, Our Supreme Court has endorsed the idea that private clinics for the rich, should be allowed. Paul Martin advocated the abolition of the “notwithstanding clause” in our Constitution, which would allow the courts to make law in this country- at least in defiance of the federal government. That’s an undemocratic and immoral position and completely contrary to Canadian traditions and values. That elitist Court has already begun to destroy our public health system.

Stephen Harper would allow private clinics, at which the rich could pay a fee of say- $2500.00- so that they would never have to wait for anything. The multi-payer insurance system in the United States is something Harper and his band of ”reform/conservatives” would adopt in Canada either in whole, or in some modified form.

There’s another irony in the U.S. of A. when it comes to health care, which can be found at the American Veterans’ Administration. The Veterans healthcare system follows the Canadian model. It’s a universal system, funded and operated by the government and covers all veterans. According to a recent article in the New York Times, the U.S. Veterans’ socialized healthcare system is more efficient and better organized than the private system because, like the Canadian one, it’s operated as an integrated, universal, single-payer entity.

Our public health system is facing problems…not because it’s a bad system, but rather because some politicians and others are willing to allow it to be sacrificed on the altar of greed, by not funding it properly. Privatizing our healthcare system will make the system more bureaucratic, not less. It will make healthcare more expensive, not less. And it will put good care out of the reach of many middle and lower-income Canadians.
Our Canadian system needs reform, improvement, more money and more help for those who depend on good healthcare and the drug prescriptions they require for survival. But it’s an excellent system that Canadians have now and a majority of Americans would love to have.
Here’s a quote from a recent letter to the editor from an American in California: “I make a decent income, but between my adjustable-rate mortgage and the $16,000 a year I must pay for health insurance, I am never that far away from bankruptcy and homelessness. Yet somehow I think my situation is still better than that of many Americans- Bill Godnick, Fair Oaks Calif.

Write, or phone your local MP/MPP and let them know that they have a duty and a responsibility to preserve and improve one of our most important essential services. Canadian apathy could well result in the disappearance of one of this country’s proudest accomplishments.